11-Oct 22:33, by E17 Addick

Sometimes constructing mutual teams can be a challenge because although there are plenty of players who have played for both sides, there can be a deficit in certain positions. 

This is the case with Donny where our man in the East is creative about the central defence.


David Button. 
Capped by England up to Under-20 level, remarkably David went on loan from Spurs 12 times and only played for the White Hart Lane club once as a late substitute at Doncaster in the League Cup in 2009. 

He later returned to the Keepmoat and played seven times for Rovers on loan. 

When he finally left Tottenham in 2012 he spent a season with the Addicks before moving on to Brentford and then Fulham.

Carl Ikeme also played on loan for Rovers as did Ben Alnwick, who never actually played for their first team.‎


Right-back .

Fraser Richardson . 
Frazer spent the 2009/10 season as an Addick . He ended his career at Doncaster in 2016 playing four times . He also played for Leeds , Stoke , Southampton , Middlesbrough , Ipswich and Rotherham .

Centre backs. 

John Vickers . Defender  John played 39 times for Rovers in a two year spell in 1930 . He moved to the Valley and played 10 times for Charlton in their relegation season of 1932/33 .

Yun Suk Young . I will put Left-back Young at centre back on the basis that he is nearly six foot tall . He had loan spells at both clubs whilst a QPR player 


Cedric Evina . Ceddy is still a Doncaster player and has made 77 appearances since transferring from Charlton in 2014 . . He is currently on loan at Crawley .


Simeon Hodson also represented both clubs.‎


Right Midfield Neil Redfearn . 
Neil joined Doncaster from  Lincoln in 1986 before earning a big move to Watford in 1989 . Via Crystal Palace , Oldham and Barnsley, a then record £1 Million move to Charlton in 1998 meant that he featured in the Addicks first ever Premiership season.

Central Midfield . 
Paul Gilchrist An FA Cup winner with Southampton in 1976 . Swanley born Paul started at Charlton and made seven appearances between 1968 and 1971 . He then moved to Rovers for a season before First Division Southampton signed him .

Graham Moore . A move to Charlton revitalised Graham’s career in 1967 after his transfer from Northampton . He even earned him a Welsh international recall. In his earlier career he played for Cardiff, Chelsea and Manchester United. He ended his career at Doncaster where his manager was his ex-Charlton colleague Maurice Setters.

Left Midfield .
Franck Moussa .Most recently at Walsall, Franck played 14 times for Doncaster on loan from Leicester in 2011 .He played for Charlton between 2014 and 2016 .  
Other options were Dany N’Guessen , Cameron Stewart ,Garry Kimble and Abdul Razak .


Jason Euell . Current Addicks Under-21 coach, Jamaican International  Jason had two playing spells at The Valley and made 12 appearances for Rovers on loan from Blackpool in 2011 .

Clive Mendocna . Clive made two appearances on loan for Doncaster in 1988 whilst at Sheffield United . He joined Charlton from Grimsby in 1997 scoring 45 times in 96 matches including the memorable hat trick in the play-off final .

Paul Gorman was another option.

Ex Charlton player Maurice Setters managed Doncaster. He can be assisted by current Sunderland Assistant Manager, ex Rovers player Glynn Snodin, who assisted Alan Curbishley during Charlton’s Premiership years.


have your say   |   back to article list   |   [Hit count for this article: 939]